The treaty's borders were far smaller than today's national boundary.
In 1824 a second treaty ceded the entire island to the British East India Company, with lifetime annuities for the Sultan and the Temenggong. Arrangements of this kind were not unusual in the Malay world of the period, but this one fixed a framework with long consequences: sovereignty over land and sovereignty over people were separated, then transferred.
What the treaty left unsettled was who actually held the land. Kampong residents had farmed, fished and tapped rubber for generations with no notion of a title deed. Once the British land registry arrived, large areas of customary use were redefined as Crown land or as land without an owner.
The effects run to the present. More than 80 percent of the island is state land, assembled through compulsory acquisition, reclamation and purchase. That gives the government unusual executive capacity in planning, housing and infrastructure. It is also the condition underneath the HDB programme, the MRT alignments and the reclamation scheme.
Only with that in view does it make sense that the island could be redrawn inside one generation. The question was never efficiency. It was the structure of property.